MAC Paint Pot Inspired Products: The 2 Drugstore Alternatives I Love

MAC Paint Pot Dupe

Hi friends! I’ve received over a dozen messages praising Lano’s Face Base Vitamin E Day Cream after publishing my last beauty article , and I’m so glad to hear you’re loving this miracle cream! Today I’m sharing my favorite drugstore alternatives for another beauty product staple: the beloved MAC Paint Pot. I’ve had a paint pot in my makeup bag since early high school (I’m a MAC lover through and through!), but after a few weeks of trial and error I’m excited to share two drugstore alternatives that truly give the original product a run for its money. Looking for a product similar to the MAC Paint Pot? Keep reading for my two top picks!

FIRST: WHY I LOVE THE ORIGINAL

Mac’s Pro Longwear Paint Pot Eyeshadow (available in nearly all shades on Ulta.com) is a long-wear eye primer and cream shadow in one. The highly pigmented shades can be worn alone or under products for a flawless, creaseless look. Toting an impressive 24 hour wear claim, this product goes on smoothly and dries to the perfect consistency for beautiful, buildable coverage.

While Painterly (a gorgeous nude/beige) is the brand’s hero shade, I’m a big fan of Layin Low for its matte, creamy beige finish. I wear as a standalone shadow for daily makeup looks, or as an eyeshadow primer for heavier glam days. I personally love that it covers any eyelid imperfections (for me – small veins, discoloration, etc.) while providing the perfect dose of natural color. The 0.17oz pots retail at $23.

“You could die wearing M.A.C. Paint Pot pigment, and two years later, there would still be remnants of the product on your lids.”

-Kristofer Buckle, Mariah Carey’s makeup artist who used the product for her “I’ll Be Lovin’ You Long Time” video shoot. Source:Allure

MAC PAINT POT DRUGSTORE ALTERNATIVE #1: MAYBELLINE COLOR TATTOO

MAC PAINT POT DUPE

Overview – Mac Paint Pot Inspired Product #1

Dubbed Best Makeup Steal of 2020 in the Allure Best of Beauty Awards, this first product is seriously incredible. Mirroring MAC’s Paint Pot, Maybelline’s Color Tattoo boasts crease-resistant, fade-resistant, and waterproof claims — and matches MAC’s 24-hour wear promise. The Color Tattoo comes in a variety of shades – both matte and shimmer – and has acquired quite the cult following since its initial 2019 launch.

My Thoughts

I decided on the shade V.I.P in an effort to replicate the beige, matte look of MAC’s Layin Low, and I was thrilled by how similar the products were.The colors appeared nearly identical on my skin tone, although I did find that Maybelline’s version appeared slightly pinker as the day went on. Some reviewers claim this product dries out quickly, but I kept it fresh with a spritz of setting powder and have not noticed a change in consistency since purchasing several weeks ago. Overall: gorgeous color, great all-day finish, and a price that doesn’t break the bank. This is definitely a product worth adding to your makeup bag.

MAC PAINT POT DRUGSTORE ALTERNATIVE #2: COLOURPOP CREAM EYESHADOW

MAC PAINT POT DUPE

Overview – Mac Paint Pot Inspired Product #2

I’ve always been a fan of Colourpop’s solid eyeshadow trays and their incredible lip stains (fun fact – they share an interesting link with Kylie Cosmetics/Lip Kits!). Their products are high quality and incredibly affordable, with everything priced under $10. After seeing a Tik Tok featuring their cream eyeshadow as a MAC’s Paint Pot inspired alternative, I ran (or scrolled) to Ulta.com as fast as I could. Boasting similar claims to the previous two – with exception of the 24 hour wear specification – the primer and shadow in one is crease proof, long-wearing, and water resistant.

My Thoughts

After reading several reviews, I decided on the shade Laurel – a soft, pinky nude that mimics MAC’s Painterly. The products are nearly identical in texture, and both applied seamlessly while staying true to their all-day claims. Laurel is a bit pinker in tone than Painterly, but both worked incredibly well as eyeshadow primers and standalone shadows. I specifically loved the consistency of the Colourpop version — a little silkier than MAC and a little slower to dry. This product is incredible and receives 5 stars from me!

Final Thoughts

After several weeks of experimenting with these two products (among 5 other potential products that I didn’t like enough to share), I can honestly say I’ll be keeping both products in my kit for years to come. From a texture and overall comparison standpoint, Colourpop absolutely nailed it, but I find myself wearing Maybelline’s V.I.P as a standalone product more frequently. Both look fabulous under my daily eyeshadow, and after a few weeks both have kept their consistency without cracking or drying. I love the all-day wear claims, and with the matching $8 price tags I’m excited to experiment with more shades!

Looking for more beauty-related content? You can view all past articles here, or if there’s something specific you’d like to see, please send me an inquiry! Thank you so much for stopping by — I hope this article was helpful, and I hope you’ll give these two heavy-hitting drugstore products a try.

Until next time,

Lane Creatore Signature

This post contains affiliate links.  If you click on an affiliate link and later make a purchase, I may receive a small commission. Read my full disclosure statement {here}

Are You on The List? Let's Stay in Touch.

Coming soon. Sign up to receive weekly designer-inspired finds, exclusive content, and much more. I can not wait to connect with you!

Let's Get Social.

Hi, I'm Lane!

I'm an NYC-based content creator and photographer sharing my favorite fashion finds. I'm so thankful you're here!

Comments?

  1. 10.11.21

    Thank you so much, Ana!

  2. 10.11.21

    Thank you for stopping by, Bia! Really appreciate it 🙂

  3. 10.11.21

    I’m so glad you enjoyed it Rebeka! Thank you for the sweet comment 🙂